Manchester City won a chaotic derby at Etihad Stadium

Man City 1

Agüero 63′

Man Utd 0

• FT 90 +6
• HT 0-0

By Phil McNulty Chief football writer at Etihad Stadium

• Man City record first win in four games
• United's Smalling sent off in first half
• Aguero scores 11th goal in 12 league games

Manchester City won a chaotic derby at Etihad Stadium as Sergio Aguero's second-half strike gave the Premier League champions victory over Manchester United.

Aguero's 10th Premier League goal of the season finally breached a depleted United defence after Chris Smalling had been sent off in the first half and Marcos Rojo taken off on a stretcher after the break with shoulder damage.
It also brought a shaft of light to a disappointing week that had seen manager Manuel Pellegrini's side lose at West Ham in the league then see their Capital One Cup defence ended at home by Newcastle.

Play media

Jump media player

Media player help

Out of media player. Press enter to return or tab to continue.

Man City 1-0 Man Utd: Pellegrini says penalty decisions were 'clear'

In a game that was played on the edge of ill-discipline and often strayed into it, Aguero's goal will have felt like vindication to City and their fans, infuriated at seeing a succession of presentable penalty appeals rejected by referee Michael Oliver.
Most significantly, it kept leaders Chelsea in the champions' sights, albeit with a six-point advantage and four ahead of second-placed Southampton.
This was a compelling derby, the first for new United manager Louis van Gaal, who saw his defence stripped bare and the attacking riches of Angel Di Maria, Robin van Persie and Wayne Rooney - returning from suspension - fail to fire.
The Dutchman will be furious at the unnecessary way in which Smalling was dismissed, while the hosts will be happy their mini-slump was ended by a sixth win in the last seven Manchester derbies in the Premier League.
Nerves and tempers were frayed towards the end as United mounted a recovery of sorts and while this was not the sort of display to have Jose Mourinho and Chelsea looking anxiously over their shoulders, victory was all that mattered to City after recent mishaps.

Former Wales international Robbie Savage:
"Manchester United are level on points with West Brom. Don't get me wrong, I think Alan Irvine is doing a great job there, but United have spent £150m on new players and that is unacceptable. When are we going to start asking serious questions of Louis van Gaal in press conferences because I haven't heard it yet."

Such was the combustible nature of the first half, with quality at a premium, that it was inevitable players from both sides would be running the risk of a red card.
Rooney harangued referee Oliver to demand a booking for Pablo Zabaleta while England keeper Joe Hart was right in the official's face when Daley Blind kicked the ball away having already been booked.
Amid the mayhem, United keeper David de Gea demonstrated his growing stature with a superb reflex save from Jesus Navas before diving bravely at the feet of Aguero, both players collecting an injury in the process.
When the red card came, it was in the most irresponsible manner imaginable. Smalling had been needlessly booked for charging down Hart's clearance then launched himself at James Milner in a manner that was only going to end one way.

Play media

Jump media player

Media player help

Out of media player. Press enter to return or tab to continue.

Man City 1-0 Man Utd: Smalling's second yellow stupid - Van Gaal

The centre-half was studiously ignored by United's management team as he made his way off, Michael Carrick replacing Adnan Januzaj as Van Gaal was forced into a defensive redesign.
Temperatures were rising on and off the pitch as referee Oliver refused to answer several home demands for penalties, particularly when Fellaini clashed with Aguero before half-time and again after the interval when he attempted to dart between the Belgian and Carrick in the area.
United's defensive resources were further reduced when Rojo was taken off on a stretcher after damaging his shoulder diving into a challenge on Martin Demichelis. Teenager Paddy McNair came into a makeshift rearguard.
It was impossible to see the visitors keeping City out - and they did not. The breakthrough came after 62 minutes when Yaya Toure's pass cleared space on the left flank for Gael Clichy, whose cross was met expertly by Aguero, pulling away from defenders to flash a powerful finish high past De Gea.
Navas struck a post as City tried to confirm their advantage but suddenly, against all odds, United became a threat as Hart saved from Van Persie and Di Maria, while Fellaini headed hopelessly wide from eight yards.
Five minutes of stoppage time had the nerves jangling around the Etihad, but City closed out a crucial win.

Manchester United have recorded just two clean sheets all season

No Premier League team has had more players sent off than Manchester United in 2014 (5)

Marcos Rojo was injured for Manchester United, meaning the away side finished the game with a completely different pairing in the centre of defence

Sergio Aguero has scored 11 goals in his last 12 Premier League appearances

Man City have won the last four Manchester derbies in the Premier League - the first time they have won four in a row in the league since 1970

Lineup, Bookings (6) & Substitutions (6)

Manchester City

• 01 Hart
• 05 Zabaleta Booked
• 04 Kompany
• 26 Demichelis Booked
• 22 Clichy
• 15 Jesús Navas
• 42 Y Touré
• 06 Fernando Booked
• 07 Milner (Nasri - 70' )
• 16 Agüero (Fernandinho - 84' )
• 35 Jovetic (Dzeko - 71' )

Substitutes

• 03 Sagna
• 08 Nasri
• 10 Dzeko
• 12 Sinclair
• 13 Caballero
• 25 Fernandinho
• 38 Boyata

Manchester United

• 01 de Gea
• 25 A Valencia
• 12 Smalling Dismissed after an earlier booking
• 05 Rojo (McNair - 56' )
• 03 Shaw
• 17 Blind Booked
• 11 Januzaj (Carrick - 43' )
• 31 Fellaini
• 10 Rooney
• 07 Di María
• 20 van Persie (Wilson - 82' )

Substitutes

• 08 Mata
• 13 Lindegaard
• 16 Carrick
• 21 Herrera
• 24 Fletcher
• 33 McNair
• 49 Wilson

Ref: Michael Oliver

Att: 45,358

Match Stats

Shots

                                     16                                         9

On target

                                       6                                         2

Corners

                                        7                                        4

Fouls

                                      15                                       9

Live Text Commentary

Full time

Full Time Match ends, Manchester City 1, Manchester United 0.

90:00 +5:13 Full time

Full Time Second Half ends, Manchester City 1, Manchester United 0.

90:00 +2:37 Offside, Manchester United. Daley Blind tries a through ball, but Marouane Fellaini is caught offside.
90:00 +2:19 Foul by Vincent Kompany (Manchester City).
90:00 +2:19 Marouane Fellaini (Manchester United) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
90:00 +1:20 Corner, Manchester United. Conceded by Gaël Clichy.
90:00 +0:57 Corner, Manchester United. Conceded by Vincent Kompany.
90:00 +0:22 Attempt missed. Yaya Touré (Manchester City) header from the centre of the box is just a bit too high. Assisted by Fernandinho with a cross following a corner.
89:51 Corner, Manchester City. Conceded by Luke Shaw.
88:42 Attempt missed. Yaya Touré (Manchester City) right footed shot from outside the box is close, but misses to the right. Assisted by Fernandinho.
86:29 Delay over. They are ready to continue.
85:57 Delay in match Wayne Rooney (Manchester United) because of an injury.
85:25 Attempt blocked. Ángel Di María (Manchester United) left footed shot from outside the box is blocked. Assisted by Wayne Rooney.
84:29 Attempt missed. Marouane Fellaini (Manchester United) header from the centre of the box is too high. Assisted by Ángel Di María with a cross following a corner.
84:05 Corner, Manchester United. Conceded by Vincent Kompany.
83:23 Hand ball by Fernandinho (Manchester City).
83:05 Substitution

Substitution Substitution, Manchester City. Fernandinho replaces Sergio Agüero.

81:19 Substitution

Substitution Substitution, Manchester United. James Wilson replaces Robin van Persie.

80:57 Foul by Samir Nasri (Manchester City).
80:57 Marouane Fellaini (Manchester United) wins a free kick on the right wing.